LIMAFOX76 at 18:19, 3 February 2016

2016-02-03T18:19:27Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:19, 3 February 2016
Line 4:		Line 4:
	\| caption = The ''Stargate Atlantis'' screen logo		\| caption = The ''Stargate Atlantis'' screen logo
	\| show_name_2 =		\| show_name_2 =
	\| genre = ~~[[Show genre::Military science fiction]]<br/>[[Show genre::Adventure science fiction]]~~		\| genre = series
	\| format =		\| format =
	\| creator = [[created by::Brad Wright]]<br/>[[Created by::Robert C. Cooper]]		\| creator = [[created by::Brad Wright]]<br/>[[Created by::Robert C. Cooper]]

LIMAFOX76: /* Critical reception */

2016-02-02T12:24:08Z

Critical reception

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:24, 2 February 2016
Line 158:		Line 158:
	David Nusair from ''Reel Film Reviews'' reviewing "[[Rising]]" said "as a [[wikipedia:pilot episode\|pilot episode]], there's no denying that "Rising" gets the job done," commenting to the one episode release of the pilot on [[DVD]] format.<ref name="RFR">{{cite web\|author=David Nusair \|url=http://www.reelfilm.com/tvsgaris.htm \|title=Stargate: Atlantis "Rising" \|publisher=''Reel Film Reviews'' \| language=\| accessdate=2009-04-03}}</ref> ''Critical Myth'' rated {{ep\|Adrift}} 8 out of 10, praising the direction the writers took with the episode, Sheppard being rather forced to be in command of the city with the incapacitation of Weir, as well as comparing the characters' "chance to prove their mettle through extreme adversity" to {{ep\|The Siege, Part 2}}.<ref>{{cite web \|url=http://entil2001.com/blog7/?p=25 \|title=Stargate Review Blog » Blog Archive » Episode 4.1: "Adrift" \|date=October 2, 2007 \|accessdate=April 24, 2009 \|publisher=Critical Myth}}</ref> Marx Pyle of the ''[[SyFy Portal]]'' (which was since renamed ''[[Airlock Alpha]]'') described the episode {{ep\|The Daedalus Variations}} as Atlantis' version of ''[[wikipedia:Star Trek: The Next Generation\|Star Trek: The Next Generation]]'' episode "[[wikipedia:Q Who?\|Q Who?]]". It was praised for being a "fun filler" episode, and Pyle enjoyed the scene where the two Sheppards converse, and the space battle, believing only ''[[battlestar:Battlestar Galactica (TRS)\|Battlestar Galactica]]'' could beat them. However, Pyle criticised the episode for the absence of [[Richard Woolsey\|Woolsey]], and McKay's apparent quick understanding of new technologies including the alternate reality drive, as well as feeling that Sci Fi gave away too much information from the previews of the episode.<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://www.airlockalpha.com/news425269pall.html \|title=Review: 'Stargate Atlantis' - The Daedalus Variations \|work=SyFy Portal \|first=Marx \|last=Pyle \|date=2008-08-03\|accessdate=2009-03-31}}</ref> When reviewing {{ep\|Enemy at the Gate}}, ''[[wikipedia:IGN\|IGN]]'' reviewer Tory Ireland Mell has given the episode a "mediocre" score of 5.8 out of 10, where the reviewer felt that everything on the episode was "forced", and felt the final scene was "uninspiring", though the episode was praised for the conversation between Sheppard and Carter.<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://uk.tv.ign.com/articles/942/942761p1.html \|title=Stargate Atlantis: "Enemy at the Gate" Review \|work=IGN \|first=Tory Ireland \|last=Mell \|date=January 8, 2009 \|accessdate=2009-01-15}}</ref>		David Nusair from ''Reel Film Reviews'' reviewing "[[Rising]]" said "as a [[wikipedia:pilot episode\|pilot episode]], there's no denying that "Rising" gets the job done," commenting to the one episode release of the pilot on [[DVD]] format.<ref name="RFR">{{cite web\|author=David Nusair \|url=http://www.reelfilm.com/tvsgaris.htm \|title=Stargate: Atlantis "Rising" \|publisher=''Reel Film Reviews'' \| language=\| accessdate=2009-04-03}}</ref> ''Critical Myth'' rated {{ep\|Adrift}} 8 out of 10, praising the direction the writers took with the episode, Sheppard being rather forced to be in command of the city with the incapacitation of Weir, as well as comparing the characters' "chance to prove their mettle through extreme adversity" to {{ep\|The Siege, Part 2}}.<ref>{{cite web \|url=http://entil2001.com/blog7/?p=25 \|title=Stargate Review Blog » Blog Archive » Episode 4.1: "Adrift" \|date=October 2, 2007 \|accessdate=April 24, 2009 \|publisher=Critical Myth}}</ref> Marx Pyle of the ''[[SyFy Portal]]'' (which was since renamed ''[[Airlock Alpha]]'') described the episode {{ep\|The Daedalus Variations}} as Atlantis' version of ''[[wikipedia:Star Trek: The Next Generation\|Star Trek: The Next Generation]]'' episode "[[wikipedia:Q Who?\|Q Who?]]". It was praised for being a "fun filler" episode, and Pyle enjoyed the scene where the two Sheppards converse, and the space battle, believing only ''[[battlestar:Battlestar Galactica (TRS)\|Battlestar Galactica]]'' could beat them. However, Pyle criticised the episode for the absence of [[Richard Woolsey\|Woolsey]], and McKay's apparent quick understanding of new technologies including the alternate reality drive, as well as feeling that Sci Fi gave away too much information from the previews of the episode.<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://www.airlockalpha.com/news425269pall.html \|title=Review: 'Stargate Atlantis' - The Daedalus Variations \|work=SyFy Portal \|first=Marx \|last=Pyle \|date=2008-08-03\|accessdate=2009-03-31}}</ref> When reviewing {{ep\|Enemy at the Gate}}, ''[[wikipedia:IGN\|IGN]]'' reviewer Tory Ireland Mell has given the episode a "mediocre" score of 5.8 out of 10, where the reviewer felt that everything on the episode was "forced", and felt the final scene was "uninspiring", though the episode was praised for the conversation between Sheppard and Carter.<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://uk.tv.ign.com/articles/942/942761p1.html \|title=Stargate Atlantis: "Enemy at the Gate" Review \|work=IGN \|first=Tory Ireland \|last=Mell \|date=January 8, 2009 \|accessdate=2009-01-15}}</ref>

	[[Stargate Atlantis Season 1\|Season one]] of ''Stargate Atlantis'' garnered mixed to positive reviews. John Sinnott from ''[[wikipedia:DVDTalk\|DVDTalk]]'' called season one a "very good spinoff," certifying it "highly recommended."<ref name="dvdtalk">{{cite news \|first=John \|last=Sinnott \|url=http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/18769/stargate-atlantis-the-complete-first-season/ \|title=Stargate Atlantis - The Complete First Season \|publisher=''DVDTalk'' \|date=November 16, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Dan Heaton from ''Digitally Obsessed'' was positive to the first season, and said the pilot started "in fashion."<ref name="digitallyobsessed">{{cite news \|first=Dan \|last= Heaton \|url=http://www.digitallyobsessed.com/displaylegacy.php?ID=8103 \|title=Stargate Atlantis: The Complete First Season \|publisher=''Digitally Obsessed'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Reviewer Dan Phelps from ''DVDFanatic'' gave the series "thumbs up" and gave the series an A-.<ref name="dvdfanatic">{{cite news \|first=Dan \|last=Phelps \|url=http://www.dvdfanatic.com/news.php?id=0511192 \|title=DVD Review: "Stargate Atlantis - The Complete First Season" \|publisher=''DVDFanatic'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Oladotun Ogunsulire from ''Science Fiction Buzz'' said the series should be "treasured."<ref name="sciencefictionbuzz">{{cite news \|last=Oladotun \|first= Ogunsulire \|url=http://blog.sciencefictionbuzz.com/4400/review-of-stargate-atlantis-season-one/ \|title=Review Of Stargate Atlantis - Season One \|publisher=''Science Fiction Buzz'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> June L. from ''Monsters and Critics'' (M&C) gave [[Stargate Atlantis Season 2\|season two]] of ''Stargate Atlantis'' 4 out of 5, and said that it was a "pleasure to watch the stories", compared to other new [[science fiction]] shows which depend on "blood and violence."<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://www.monstersandcritics.com/dvd/reviews/article_1274075.php/DVD_Review_Stargate_Atlantis_-_The_Complete_Second_Season \|title=DVD Review: Stargate Atlantis - The Complete Second Season \|first=L. \|last=June \|date=March 7, 2007 \|accessdate=2009-05-10 \|work=Monsters and Critics ~~\| author=June L.~~}}</ref>		[[Stargate Atlantis Season 1\|Season one]] of ''Stargate Atlantis'' garnered mixed to positive reviews. John Sinnott from ''[[wikipedia:DVDTalk\|DVDTalk]]'' called season one a "very good spinoff," certifying it "highly recommended."<ref name="dvdtalk">{{cite news \|first=John \|last=Sinnott \|url=http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/18769/stargate-atlantis-the-complete-first-season/ \|title=Stargate Atlantis - The Complete First Season \|publisher=''DVDTalk'' \|date=November 16, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Dan Heaton from ''Digitally Obsessed'' was positive to the first season, and said the pilot started "in fashion."<ref name="digitallyobsessed">{{cite news \|first=Dan \|last= Heaton \|url=http://www.digitallyobsessed.com/displaylegacy.php?ID=8103 \|title=Stargate Atlantis: The Complete First Season \|publisher=''Digitally Obsessed'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Reviewer Dan Phelps from ''DVDFanatic'' gave the series "thumbs up" and gave the series an A-.<ref name="dvdfanatic">{{cite news \|first=Dan \|last=Phelps \|url=http://www.dvdfanatic.com/news.php?id=0511192 \|title=DVD Review: "Stargate Atlantis - The Complete First Season" \|publisher=''DVDFanatic'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> Oladotun Ogunsulire from ''Science Fiction Buzz'' said the series should be "treasured."<ref name="sciencefictionbuzz">{{cite news \|last=Oladotun \|first= Ogunsulire \|url=http://blog.sciencefictionbuzz.com/4400/review-of-stargate-atlantis-season-one/ \|title=Review Of Stargate Atlantis - Season One \|publisher=''Science Fiction Buzz'' \|date=November 15, 2005 \|accessdate=2009-05-23}}</ref> June L. from ''Monsters and Critics'' (M&C) gave [[Stargate Atlantis Season 2\|season two]] of ''Stargate Atlantis'' 4 out of 5, and said that it was a "pleasure to watch the stories", compared to other new [[science fiction]] shows which depend on "blood and violence."<ref>{{cite news \|url=http://www.monstersandcritics.com/dvd/reviews/article_1274075.php/DVD_Review_Stargate_Atlantis_-_The_Complete_Second_Season \|title=DVD Review: Stargate Atlantis - The Complete Second Season \|first=L. \|last=June \|date=March 7, 2007 \|accessdate=2009-05-10 \|work=Monsters and Critics }}</ref>

	=== Awards and nominations ===		=== Awards and nominations ===

LIMAFOX76 at 12:21, 2 February 2016

2016-02-02T12:21:06Z

Show changes

LIMAFOX76: Created page with "{{Infobox Television | show_name = Stargate Atlantis | image = Stargate Atlantis logo.jpg | caption = The ''Stargate Atlantis'' scree..."

2016-02-02T12:12:49Z

Created page with "{{Infobox Television | show_name = Stargate Atlantis | image = Stargate Atlantis logo.jpg | caption = The ''Stargate Atlantis'' scree..."

Show changes

Stargate Atlantis - Revision history

LIMAFOX76 at 18:19, 3 February 2016

LIMAFOX76: /* Critical reception */

LIMAFOX76 at 12:21, 2 February 2016

LIMAFOX76: Created page with "{{Infobox Television | show_name = Stargate Atlantis | image = Stargate Atlantis logo.jpg | caption = The ''Stargate Atlantis'' scree..."